Final Thoughts: Gunslinger Girl Il Teatrino

With terrorist attacks continuing to plague Italy, the cyborg girls of Section 2 are needed more than ever- and through a mixture of conditioning and adolescent, they are more than willing to fight alongside their handlers. But even the enhanced abilities of a cyborg may not be enough to combat the likes of naturally gifted killer Pinocchio- especially as some of the older girls must confront their own mortality as their life spans run short.

As someone who ranks both the Gunslinger Girl manga and the first season of the anime amongst my all-time favourites, a continuation of the animated version seemed like an early Christmas present. Unfortunately, when it transpired that Studio Madhouse was handing over the reins to Artland, the warning bells began to go off- and unfortunately even my lowered expectations weren’t prepared for the awful reality.

Where the original series added colour, music and atmosphere to the material without compromising on the quality in any way, Il Teatrino was little more than an exercise in how to ruin good ingredients. Somehow forgetting everything they did for Mushishi, Artland threw away the depth and poignancy of the series, replacing it with something bland and shallow. In the manga, I cared for all the characters, but here I was barely motivated enough to watch them- it wasn’t just that I knew what was coming, it was all just handled so shoddily.

As if to add insult to injury, the series couldn’t manage to offer up a bit of eye candy to compensate for its many flaws in content. Instead, Il Teatrino is visually inferior to the first series, offering simplified character designs that are of average quality at best and an insult to the original anime at worst. Similarly, the wonderfully atmospheric background music of the first season has been replaced with generic anime themes that will impress no one.

Final Thoughts

Before this series came along, I would have sworn that it was impossible to ruin something as good as Gunslinger Girl, but Artland have proven themselves more than able for the task. A disappointing addition to an otherwise strong franchise, this is one anime that should probably be put to one side- it may not be the worst series out there, but its very existence sullies the good name of Gunslinger Girl.

Tier: Wood+

This entry was posted in Series reviews and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Final Thoughts: Gunslinger Girl Il Teatrino

  1. Sasa says:

    Holy… you actually managed to remind me that I have completely forgotten about Gunslinger Girl Il Teatrino. XD That probably shows how underwhelming I have found it to be myself, but on the other hand, I think it’s still a nice show compared to many other anime I have watched in the past. Personally, I have felt a lot of the original atmosphere was still there, when you ignore the moefication of the girls. I think the music helped (I still listen to the soundtrack from time to time!)

  2. I’ve more or less stopped keeping track of the series around episode 7 and it looks like my decision to halt watching that series was a good idea. I remember being a bit annoyed at the first episode and its surprising lack of detail. It’s like they took Madhouse’s stellar adaptation and did some unmentionable things to the point where the overall quality just plummeted.

  3. ritchan says:

    Yeah, I found that Il Teatrino sucked major balls. It was really disappointing, but the Pinocchio antagonist sounded interesting, and there was for once some common enemy. What happened? I stopped watching after episode 5 or so 😀
    Everything I hated about it (pretty much everything) I detailed here:

    Did you notice the awesome music was also gone?

  4. Rewarp says:

    I myself refused to believe what my net friends have said of Gunslinger Girl’s second season. But as it seemed to be a united opinion, I stayed away from the 2nd season.

    Then my fellow otaku roommate played Il Teatrino, and when I heard the intense emotion from Henrietta’s voice actor, I decided to curse Artland for destroying the first anime that was compelling enough for me to watch it 4 times over Animax and to buy the rather expensive manga.

    I can only hope MadHouse re-animates the 2nd season.

Comments are closed.